Brief #068 · SEA LAW
Does a captain really have to go down with the ship?
Stories
No international convention makes a captain go down with the ship: that's tradition, not a treaty. Finnish and Swedish law even put it in writing: the master must not abandon a ship while there's reasonable hope of saving her, unless his own life is in serious danger. Leaving early can still be a crime. Italy's navigation code says the commander must leave the ship last, with prison for not doing so. The Costa Concordia wrecked off Giglio on 13 January 2012, and 32 people died. In February 2015 her captain, Francesco Schettino, was sentenced to 16 years and one month: 10 years for manslaughter, 5 for causing the shipwreck, 1 for abandoning ship and 1 month for false communications to the maritime authorities. Italy's highest court upheld the sentence in May 2017, and its reasons say a captain has no unconditional duty to sink with his ship, but must keep command for as long as he can usefully help the people on board. Rules differ by country: lawyers say English and US law have no statute making the master the last to leave. So the law doesn't ask a captain to die. But it can punish leaving before the passengers.
Maritime law differs by country. This covers IMO conventions and the national laws it names. Not legal advice.
Transcript
Does a captain really have to go down with the ship?
Everyone thinks they know the rules of the sea. Test yourself at theskippersbrief.com. But first, the answer.
No. That's tradition, not a treaty.
Finnish and Swedish law say: stay while there's reasonable hope of saving her, unless your own life is in serious danger. But Italy's code says the captain must leave last.
Costa Concordia, 2012. 32 people died. Her captain was sentenced to 16 years. Ten for manslaughter, five for causing the wreck, one for abandoning ship.
The law doesn't ask a captain to die. But it can punish leaving before the passengers.
Try three free questions at theskippersbrief.com.
Sources
- ABC News, 'Captains Who Abandon Ships: Are They Breaking the Law?' (April 2014), quoting IMO spokesman Lee Adamson: 'There is nothing in any IMO Convention to specifically require a captain to stay on board the vessel', 'however he/she does retain full responsibility for the safety of the vessel and those on board'. ABC: 'There is no international maritime law that requires a captain to stay on a sinking ship'; the saying 'may be more about personal choice and lore of the sea than legal responsibility'
- ABC News (April 2014), same article: Captain Francesco Schettino was 'brought up on criminal charges for abandoning the ship ahead of his passengers'
- NPR, 'Facing Disaster, What Is A Ship's Captain Expected To Do?' (17 January 2012): Bob Jarvis, maritime law professor, Nova Southeastern University: 'The captain has never been expected to be the last to leave. That's a romantic notion.' 'We certainly don't expect captains to commit suicide.'
- Jim Flannery, 'Questions of character', Soundings (July 2014): 'Though it is oft-quoted, The captain must go down with his ship is a canard'. Craig H. Allen, professor of admiralty and maritime law, University of Washington: in a few countries, including Italy, Spain and Greece, 'the law obligates a master to stay aboard a sinking vessel until the passengers and crew are safely evacuated'
- Kate Lardy, 'Are Captains Legally Required to be the Last One off the Vessel?', Dockwalk (May 2022): 'every country has its own laws'. Benjamin Maltby, Keystone Law: 'In English law, there is no law which states that the master must be the last to leave a ship in peril'. Michael Moore, US maritime attorney: 'There is absolutely no hard-and-fast rule that requires the captain to go down with the ship'. 'In Italy, a captain can face up to two years in prison for not leaving last.'
- Finland, Merilaki (Maritime Act) 674/1994, chapter 6 section 12, current consolidated text: 'Päällikkö ei saa jättää alusta niin kauan kuin on kohtuullisia toiveita sen pelastamisesta, ellei hänen henkensä ole vakavassa vaarassa' (the master may not leave the ship while there are reasonable hopes of saving her, unless his life is in serious danger). Chapter 20 section 8: leaving a ship in danger contrary to this: a fine or up to one year in prison
- Sweden, Sjölag (Maritime Code) 1994:1009, chapter 6 section 6, consolidated through SFS 2025:985: 'Så länge som det finns rimlig utsikt att fartyget kan räddas får befälhavaren inte överge det utan att hans liv är i allvarlig fara' (as long as there is a reasonable prospect of saving the ship, the master may not abandon it unless his life is in serious danger)
- Italy, Codice della navigazione (1942), art. 303: 'Il comandante deve abbandonare la nave per ultimo, provvedendo in quanto possibile a salvare le carte e i libri di bordo, e gli oggetti di valore affidati alla sua custodia' (the commander must leave the ship last)
- Italy, Codice della navigazione, art. 1097: 'Il comandante, che, in caso di abbandono della nave, del galleggiante o dell'aeromobile in pericolo, non scende per ultimo da bordo, è punito con la reclusione fino a due anni' (a commander who is not the last off a ship being abandoned in danger: up to two years in prison, more in the aggravated cases)
- CBS News (11 February 2015): a three-judge panel in Grosseto gave Francesco Schettino 'a prison sentence of 16 years and one month': '10 years for multiple counts of manslaughter', 'five years for causing the Jan. 13, 2012, shipwreck', 'one year for abandoning the ship while many of the luxury liner's 4,200 passengers and crew were still onboard', 'one month under arrest for false communications to maritime authorities'. The disaster 'killed 32 people'
- The Maritime Executive, 'No More Appeals for Schettino' (12 May 2017): Italy's highest court upheld the 16-year sentence: 10 years for manslaughter, five for causing the accident, one for abandoning the ship before passengers and crew were clear, one month for lying to the authorities afterward. 32 people died
- Diritto.it on the reasons of the Corte di Cassazione, judgment no. 35585 of 19 July 2017: Schettino definitively sentenced to '16 anni di reclusione'; he knew that 'sulla Costa Concordia erano ancora presenti centinaia di persone'. The court: the commander 'non ha l'obbligo incondizionato di affondare sempre e comunque insieme alla sua nave', but 'deve certamente mantenere il comando dello stato di pericolo fino a quando possa' 'con concreta utilità' 'aiutare le persone a bordo' (no unconditional duty to sink with his ship; he must keep command for as long as he can usefully help the people on board)
- Panorama: the Tribunale di Grosseto's sentence of '16 anni e un mese': 'dieci anni per i reati di omicidio plurimo colposo e lesioni plurime colpose', 'cinque anni per naufragio colposo', 'un anno per i reati di abbandono della nave e abbandono di incapaci'; upheld by the Cassazione in May 2017
- UPI (12 November 2015) and The Korea Herald: South Korea's Supreme Court upheld a life sentence for Lee Joon-seok, captain of the ferry Sewol, ruling his leaving the ship without warning passengers to evacuate amounted to murder; 304 people died. (Cited in the post text)