Brief #057 · BUOYAGE

Two ships hit the same wreck. How?

Navigation

In fog on 14 December 2002 the car carrier Tricolor, with 2,862 new cars, sank in the Dover Strait after a collision with the container ship Kariba, and lay on her side just under the surface, 30 m down. Two days later the cargo ship Nicola ran into the wreck, and on 1 January 2003 the tanker Vicky did too, despite guard ships, buoys and radio warnings. In busy waters, ordinary buoys don't stand out as a new danger, so in 2005 IALA, the lighthouse authorities' association, made a new buoy just for new dangers: the emergency wreck mark, blue and yellow vertical stripes with an upright yellow cross and a light that flashes blue, then yellow. Then a test: which of four buoys marks a new wreck? Blue and yellow: the wreck is new, and your chart may not show it.

The IALA Maritime Buoyage System: the emergency wreck mark is the same in Regions A and B. It marks a new danger until the danger is surveyed, charted and permanently marked.

Transcript

Two ships hit the same wreck. How?

Dover Strait, in fog: the car carrier Tricolor is hit and sinks.

She lies on her side, just under the surface.

Two days later, a cargo ship runs into her. Then a tanker. Despite guard ships, buoys and radio warnings.

Why? In all that traffic, ordinary buoys don't stand out as new.

So the lighthouse authorities made a new buoy, just for new dangers. It's in my Buoyage course.

Which one is it?

The blue and yellow one. Blue and yellow: the wreck is new, and your chart may not show it. Keep well clear.

Try three free questions at theskippersbrief.com.

Sources

  1. BEAmer (French marine accident investigation office), supplementary report on the collision between the car carrier TRICOLOR and the container vessel KARIBA on 14 December 2002 near Westhinder: 'the subsequent collisions with the wreck of the TRICOLOR of the general cargo vessel NICOLA on 16th December 2002 and the Ore/Oil carrier VICKY on 1st January 2003'; the wreck lay on her side
  2. Cedre incident sheet, Tricolor/Kariba: on 14 December 2002 at about 2.30 am the Tricolor collided with the container ship Kariba and 'sank 30 m deep in a matter of minutes, in the Pas-de-Calais, 20 miles northwest of Dunkirk', carrying '2,862 new luxury cars and 77 containers'; the wreck lay on the seabed on one side; a light buoy and a Gendarmerie Maritime patrol boat, and many radio messages, yet on 16 December the Dutch coaster Nicola 'collided with the wreck, which emerged by only a few centimetres'; cardinal buoys from 20 December; on 1 January 2003 the Turkish tanker Vicky, with 66,000 t of kerosene, hit it too
  3. House of Lords, English Channel: Collisions, 19 December 2002 (HL Deb vol 642 cc782-4): the French police vessel Glaive and HMS Anglesey are guarding the wreck of the Tricolor with two salvage boats; coastguards broadcast navigational warnings twice an hour, four an hour in bad visibility; three wreck buoys mark the site; 'the accident ... took place in thick fog'
  4. Professional Mariner, 'The Tricolor/Kariba/Clary incident': 'At night and in fog on Dec. 14, 2002', in the Westhinder branch of the traffic separation scheme; Tricolor carried more than 2,800 cars, capsized and sank with no loss of life; 'within three weeks two vessels had run up upon her partially submerged wreck and had to be pulled off'
  5. Wikipedia, MV Tricolor: she 'remained lodged on her side in the mud of the 30 metres deep waterway' and was 'just completely submerged'; 'despite standard radio warnings, three guard ships, and a lighted buoy' the Dutch vessel Nicola struck the wreck, and on 1 January 2003 the loaded fuel carrier Vicky struck it too; two more patrol ships and six more buoys were added
  6. Maritime and Coastguard Agency, Dover Strait crossings: Channel Navigation Information Service: 'Over 400 commercial vessels use the Dover Strait every day'
  7. IALA Recommendation O-133 on the Emergency Wreck Marking Buoy, Edition 1, December 2005 (adopted for use on a trial basis): 'The wreck of the Tricolor in the Dover Straits in 2002 has brought into sharp focus' how to mark new dangers quickly; 'a new wreck can be very dangerous for shipping ... even when the position is known and the wreck is properly marked'; 'the volume of traffic, background lighting and proliferation of AtoN in the area may make the deployment of cardinal or lateral marks difficult for mariners to quickly identify a new danger', so authorities may deploy a buoy 'specifically designed to mark new dangers': a pillar or spar with equal blue and yellow vertical stripes (4 to 8), an alternating blue and yellow light (B 1 s + 0.5 s + Y 1 s + 0.5 s), a standing yellow cross topmark, kept on station until the wreck is published, surveyed and permanently marked (IALA is the International Association of Marine Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities)
  8. IALA Recommendation R1001, The IALA Maritime Buoyage System, Edition 2.0 (2023), copy hosted by Irish Lights: six types of mark, the five other than lateral marks common to Regions A and B; §2.6 'New dangers may be marked with an Emergency Wreck mark': blue and yellow vertical stripes in equal number (4 to 8), pillar or spar, a vertical yellow cross topmark, a light of one second blue and one second yellow with 0.5 s eclipses; §3.2.2 new dangers 'may not yet be shown in nautical documents and publications'; for comparison §2.3–2.5: isolated danger black with red bands and two black balls, safe water red and white vertical stripes with a red ball, special marks yellow with a yellow X
  9. The Skipper's Brief, Buoyage course (live 2026-10-29): its module 'Danger, safe water, special and wreck marks' runs from the isolated danger mark to the emergency wreck buoy; every course starts with 3 free questions, no sign-up
  10. Irish Lights, IALA page: 'In the Dover strait in 1971 the Merchant Ship Brandenburg struck the wreckage of the Texaco Caribbean and sank'; a few weeks later the wreckage, despite being marked by a wreck-marking vessel and many buoys, 'was struck by the Niki, which also sank'; 'A total of 51 lives were lost'; this disaster gave rise to the IALA Maritime Buoyage System (used in the Facebook text only)
  11. House of Commons, Channel shipping accident, 1 March 1971 (HC Deb vol 812 cc1220-5): the Greek motor vessel Niki foundered off the mid Varne buoy on the evening of 27 February, probably after striking a wreck; crew of 21, no survivors; the wrecks of the Texaco Caribbean and Brandenburg were marked by Trinity House with a wreck vessel and wreck buoys (used in the Facebook text only)

Related briefs

Weekly

Get the weekly brief

One email a week with the new briefs and their sources. No spam.