Brief #074 · SEA LAW

You find a sunken ship with $500 million of treasure. Is it yours?

Stories

You find a wreck full of treasure. Is it yours? It depends whose ship it was, and where. In 2007 Odyssey Marine Exploration, a Tampa company, recovered about 594,000 coins from international waters 100 miles west of the Straits of Gibraltar, 1,100 metres down: 17 tons, estimated at up to $500 million to collectors. It claimed them in a Florida court, under the law of finds and the law of salvage. The wreck was the Spanish navy frigate Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes, which exploded in battle in 1804. US courts ruled for Spain: a sunken warship is immune from such claims, and so is her cargo. The appeals court called the wreck 'unquestionably the property of Spain', while saying it wasn't deciding who ultimately owns the coins. Spanish military planes flew them home in February 2012, and that May the Supreme Court declined to hear the case. Yet the law of finds is real: US courts held that the Atocha, a Spanish galleon lost in 1622, was abandoned, and title went to Mel Fisher's company, Treasure Salvors. Elsewhere the answer differs. In UK waters you report a find to the Receiver of Wreck within 28 days and may earn a salvage award, not ownership. Where the UNESCO 2001 convention applies, wrecks over 100 years old are generally outside the law of finds and salvage.

US court decisions, UK government guidance and the UNESCO 2001 convention. Wreck law differs from country to country, and this isn't legal advice.

Transcript

You find a sunken ship with 500 million dollars of treasure. Is it yours?

Everyone thinks they know the rules of the sea. Test yourself at theskippersbrief.com. But first, the answer.

Not when a Florida company tried it. 17 tons of coins, an estimated 500 million dollars.

But the wreck was a Spanish warship, blown apart in 1804. A US court called her unquestionably Spain's. Spain sent military planes.

But sometimes, it is yours. Mel Fisher found the Atocha, also Spanish. US courts called her abandoned, and the finder got title.

Finders keepers? Only in some waters, and only if nobody's coming back.

Try three free questions at theskippersbrief.com.

Sources

  1. Odyssey Marine Exploration v. The Unidentified Shipwrecked Vessel, 657 F.3d 1159 (11th Cir., 21 Sept 2011), slip opinion: 'In March 2007 ... Odyssey discovered a shipwreck in international waters 100 miles west of the Straits of Gibraltar at a depth of 1,100 meters'; 'Odyssey ultimately recovered approximately 594,000 coins'; a possessory and ownership claim 'pursuant to the law of finds' and a salvage claim; 'Only a few minutes after the battle began, the Mercedes exploded'; the wreck is 'the shipwreck of a sunken Spanish warship'; n.8: 'The shipwreck of the Mercedes is thus unquestionably the property of Spain', quoting the US statement that title to sunken state craft 'is not extinguished by passage of time'; n.16 on the coins: 'We do not hold the recovered res is ultimately Spanish property. Rather, we merely hold the sovereign immunity owed the shipwreck of the Mercedes also applies to any cargo'; affirmed the order to release the recovered res to Spain's custody
  2. CBS News / AP, 24 Feb 2012, 'Sunken coins bound for Spain after legal battle': a '17-ton trove of silver coins', 594,000 silver coins and other artifacts, 'estimated to be worth as much as $500 million to collectors'; 'two Spanish military C-130s' to take off from MacDill Air Force Base
  3. Fox News / AP, 20 Feb 2012, 'Salvaged treasure will be escorted to Spain by military planes': 'Tampa-based Odyssey Marine Exploration'; '594,000 coins and other artifacts' recovered in 2007; 'two Spanish Hercules transport planes will bring it back'
  4. CoinNews, 27 Feb 2012: '17-tons of sunken coin treasure', an 'estimated $500 million worth of recovered treasure'; 'Two military transport planes were sent from the Spanish Air Force to Florida'; the treasure 'landed in Madrid on Saturday'
  5. Art-Law Centre, University of Geneva (ArThemis), case note on the Mercedes (June 2015), chronology: 22 Dec 2009 district court dismisses Odyssey's claim; 21 Sept 2011 the Eleventh Circuit upholds it; 25 Feb 2012 Odyssey returned the coins to Spain; 14 May 2012 the US Supreme Court declined Odyssey's appeal
  6. US Supreme Court docket No. 11-1067, Odyssey Marine Exploration v. The Unidentified Shipwrecked Vessel: petition filed 27 Feb 2012; 'Petition DENIED', 14 May 2012
  7. ABA Journal, 'Salvage company that lost $600M sunken ship case must pay $1M to Spain for abusive litigation': Judge Steven Merryday raised a magistrate's award so that 'Odyssey must pay $1,072,979' for 'bad faith and abusive litigation'; Spain had asked for $3.3 million. Date from AP via KSL, 30 Sept 2013
  8. Treasure Salvors, Inc. v. Unidentified Wrecked and Abandoned Sailing Vessel, 569 F.2d 330 (5th Cir. 1978): 'a fleet of Spanish galleons, heavily laden with bullion'; 'The Atocha sank in the sea off the Marquesas Keys in 1622'; 'The Atocha is indisputedly an abandoned vessel'; 'The court below correctly applied the law of finds'; 'title to abandoned property vests in the person who reduces that property to his or her possession'. Title was upheld as between the plaintiffs and the United States; the court would not extend it to claimants who weren't parties
  9. Florida Dept. of State v. Treasure Salvors, 458 U.S. 670 (1982): Treasure Salvors located the wreck in 1971; 'It is apparent that the State does not have even a colorable claim to the artifacts pursuant to these contracts'; the Eleventh Amendment did not bar transferring the artifacts, though the Court did not itself decide the State's ownership
  10. CBS News, 'Treasure Hunter Mel Fisher Dies': the Nuestra Senora de Atocha, a Spanish galleon, 'went down in 1622 off Key West', with an estimated $400 million in gold, silver and gems; Fisher found traces of the site in 1971 and his son Kane found the 'mother lode' in 1985; in 1982 Fisher won his fight against Florida's claim
  11. GOV.UK, 'Wreck and salvage law': 'If you find wreck, you should assume that it has an owner'; owners have one year to come forward; a salvor who acts properly 'is likely to be entitled to a salvage award', which 'cannot exceed the salved value'; unclaimed wreck from UK waters 'becomes the property of the Crown or grantee of the Crown'
  12. GOV.UK, 'Report wreck material': 'you must report it to the Receiver of Wreck within 28 days'; 'You may be entitled to a salvage award recognising your efforts to save the item and return it to its owner'; 'If you do not report it within 28 days, you could be fined £2,500'
  13. UNESCO Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage (2001): Art. 1 covers traces of human existence underwater 'for at least 100 years'; Art. 2(7) 'Underwater cultural heritage shall not be commercially exploited'; Art. 4 activities 'shall not be subject to the law of salvage or law of finds', unless authorised, in full conformity with the Convention and ensuring maximum protection. It binds only the states that have joined it

Related briefs

Weekly

Get the weekly brief

One email a week with the new briefs and their sources. No spam.